SC orders ABC-5 to pay terminated broadcaster close to P1M


By Tetch Torres
INQUIRER.net
Last updated 11:31am (Mla time) 06/20/2007

MANILA, Philippines–The Supreme Court has ordered a broadcast company to indemnify its former newscaster for illegally dismissing her.

 

In an 11-page decision, the high court’s second division through Senior Associate Justice Leonardo Quisumbing said the Associated Broadcasting Company should pay Thelma Dumpit-Murillo almost P1 million after she was terminated illegally after four years of service.

 

The high court affirmed the decision of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) dated Aug. 30, 2000 that nullified the talent contract of Murillo whom ABC-5 dismissed on Oct. 2, 1999.

 

The high court said that based on the job description provided in Murillo’s contract, ABC-5 had control over the broadcast journalist as an employee.

 

ABC-5 had argued that Murillo was a talent and was therefore not bound by the company’s policies involving its employees and had cited previous decisions by the Supreme Court that favored this.

 

But the high court said that while it had upheld contracts between a talent and a media entity, the contract had always shown that it had been voluntarily signed by the talent.

 

In the case of Murillo, the broadcaster appeared to have not been given any choice by ABC-5 and that she was forced to sign the contract because she might not get the job.

 

The high court ordered ABC-5 to pay Murillo her one-month salary of P28,000 for every year of service, other privileges and allowances, 13th month pay, P500,000 moral damages and exemplary damages of P50,000.

Abra mayor’s arrest kept secret

‘Follow-up operations would have been compromised’

By Jeannette Andrade
Inquirer
Last updated 04:39am (Mla time) 06/20/2007

MANILA, Philippines – Where other police offices would have boasted about the arrest of a local government official and touted it as an accomplishment, the Quezon City Police District (QCPD) chose to keep secret for a week the arrest on drug trafficking charges of Bucloc, Abra Mayor Mailed Molina.

 

It was only yesterday when reports about Molina’s arrest on June 13 leaked that the QCPD presented to media the mayor and his alleged accomplices —his driver, Ricardo Verzoza, 55; and Ritchie Watanabe, a 32-year-old businessman.

 

Molina, apart from being Bucloc mayor, is the chair and commanding general of the Cordillera People’s Liberation Army who ran and lost in the Abra congressional race last month against former Abra Gov. Vicente Valera and former Lagayan, Abra Mayor Cecilia Luna.

 

QCPD public information office head Supt. Asprinio Cabula told the Inquirer that they kept Molina’s arrest under wraps because they did not want to jeopardize follow-up operations being conducted by joint operatives of the QCPD District Anti-Illegal Drugs Special Operations Task Group and Criminal Investigation and Detection Unit (CIDU).

 

“Some of our operatives conducted follow-up operations in Abra to track down the source of the illegal drugs, but unfortunately returned empty-handed,” Cabula said, stressing that there was never any attempt to hide the arrest from the public.

 

Cabula suggested that Molina probably got involved in the narcotics trade in an attempt to recover the money he spent in his campaign. Or the mayor could have been selling illegal drugs even before he ran for office, he added.

 

The police official clarified that contrary to other media reports, Molina and his companions went through inquest proceedings in the Quezon City prosecutor’s office a day after their arrest for the alleged sale of two kilos of marijuana and 800 grams of hashish or ground-up marijuana leaves as well as the illegal possession of an automatic rifle, a .45 caliber pistol and assorted ammunition.

 

Cabula said the cases of violation of Republic Act No. 9165 or the Comprehensive Dangerous Drugs Act of 2002 and illegal possession of firearms and ammunition were referred by the inquest fiscal to the Department of Justice.

 

“Molina’s lawyers filed a motion for preliminary investigation which has been granted and was set on June 22,” he added.

 

Based on a report from the CIDU, Molina and his two companions were arrested at around 11 p.m. on June 13 on Kalayaan Avenue in Barangay Central, Quezon City.

 

Before their arrest, the CIDU received information about the suspects’ illegal activities, prompting operatives to set up an entrapment operation.

 

Molina and his companions were nabbed while selling drugs to an undercover policeman on board the mayor’s silver and black Mitsubishi Strada with license plate XAK 730.

 

Molina, Verzoza and Watanabe remain in the custody of the CIDU.

Lost and found: Kapampangan words

By Tonette Orejas
Inquirer
Last updated 05:26am (Mla time) 06/20/2007

CITY OF SAN FERNANDO – What is “sipan,” “langolango,” “galang,” “yubyub,” “carangcarang,” “amuyam,” “lambangan,” “limpasut,” “talangtalang” and “batanglaua?” Or better still, “aniani,” “lualu” or “saclong?”

 

These are lost Kapampangan words that, like thousands of other terms, had been buried for nearly four centuries in the pages of a twin book by an Augustinian expert on grammar and lexicography.

 

But that was until last month when two Catholic priests in Pampanga—Edilberto Santos and Venancio Samson—completed the translation of Fray Diego Bergaño’s “Arte de la Lengua Pampanga (Grammar of the Kapampangan Language, 1729)” and “Vocabulario de Pampango (Kapampangan Vocabulary, 1732),” respectively.

 

In translating the highly regarded documents, Santos and Samson have made more available to non-scholars Bergaño’s works, which were written in Spanish.

 

Translated into Kapampangan and English and published back-to-back, the friar’s works are now easy to decipher by anyone wanting to learn the language or use the rediscovered words in everyday life.

 

“Bergaño’s books can reinvigorate the Kapampangan language by supplying it with thousands of rediscovered words, which is why I consider the translation of these books a real breakthrough in Kapampangan studies,” said Robby Tantingco, executive director of the Holy Angel University’s Juan D. Nepomuceno Center for Kapampangan Studies in Angeles City.

 

The National Commission for Culture and the Arts is co-publishing the books, which is scheduled for launch on Aug. 24 at the San Agustin Church in Intramuros, Manila. The launch, coinciding with the Language Month, is also held in honor of Bergaño who, at 23, joined the Augustinian mission in Manila in 1718.

 

Bergaño, a native of Cervera, did not intend to chronicle the words in perpetuity. His own prologue in the vocabulario said: “The most important reason why I undertook this work (writing the Kapampangan-Spanish dictionary) was my desire that, when we explain the word of God, we avoid inappropriate language.”

 

Treasure troves

 

“They are veritable treasure troves of linguistic and anthropological data,” Tantingco said. “He was able to identify the basic, original source word of all derivatives and string them up together under only one word entry, and then explained their interconnectedness. One does not achieve this by merely going around collective words.”

 

The word “buri” (like), for instance, evolves into “paburen” (neglect) and “paburian ye” (leave him alone).

 

Another, “dabpa” (in today’s version: dagpa) means “the bird on a perch spreads its wings forming a cross.” It can mean “capba” or “an arm’s length.” It can also mean the idiomatic “dimpa,” which means “befell.”

 

A related word is “dipan,” as in “Dipan na ca ning alti (May lightning strike you)!” which old folks used to curse a person they were angry with.

 

Bergaño did not do his task single-handedly. He tapped Don Juan Zuñiga of Mexico, Pampanga, to help him in the projects. These were his two of three major works.

 

The definitor (official) of Augustinians at that time, Fray Vicente Ibarra, said: “This book will finally satisfy the great desire of the ministers of the Gospel to grasp the precise meanings and connotations of those words in order to be able to speak the language correctly.”

 

Indigenous

 

Tantingco believed the dictionary itself contained “indigenous, even pre-Hispanic, conditions of the Kapampangan language and the Kapampangan themselves, but only to a certain extent.”

 

This was because the priest wrote the book 161 years after the Spanish colonizers arrived in Pampanga. In the absence of mass media, though, the rate of adulteration might have been slow and Bergaño might still have captured the nuances of the old language.

 

His text showed that the Kapampangan, a riverbank-dwelling people, possessed a sophisticated language as they had words for anything and everything around them.

 

“Sipan” is toothbrush, “langolango” is toilet, “galang” is bracelet, “yubyub” is barbecue, “carangcarang” is baby walker, “amuyam” is sponge, “lambangan” is rice dispenser, “limpasut” is shark, “talangtalang” is goldfish and “batanglaua” is spider web.

 

There are numerals from “isa” (one) to “lacsa” (10,000), “gatus” (100,000) and “sangyuta” (a million).

 

The verb “to cross legs” is “timpo” for women and “sila” for men. As for dance, it is “indac” for women and “terac” for men.

 

There are terms for times of the day, colors, body parts, family ties, flora and fauna, sex and erotica, as well as etymology of common Kapampangan surnames like “laus” (hole), “tayag” (to lift), “sagum” (to mix drinks), “ibe” (to become intoxicated from chewing betel nut), “canals” (to succeed in office), “abad” (slight wound), “tulabut” (to spurt), “viray” (boat), “calma” (luck) and “suba” (to navigate upstream).

 

Find also what Tantingco calls quaint words: “payungdaguis” (mushroom, but literally, “mouse’s umbrella”), “sulungdaguis” (morning star, “mouse’s lamp”), “sabo susu” (milk, “soup from the breast”), “bungang tudtud” (dream, “fruit of sleep”), “pinanari” (rainbow, “king’s loincloth”), and “anac sulip” (illegitimate child, “child from the basement”).

 

This was the center’s second translation project after the one on Fray Francisco Coronel’s “Arte y Reglas de la Lengua Pampanga (1621).”

 

For reservation of copies of the two books, e-mail rptmt@yahoo.com or call (045) 888-8691 local 1311 or 1312.

Typhoons, elections bring lull to Bondoc

By Delfin Mallari Jr.
Southern Luzon Bureau
Last updated 06:46am (Mla time) 06/20/2007

LUCENA CITY—All seems to be quiet these days in the Bondoc Peninsula in southern Quezon province that, in the last five years, saw farmers being abducted, killed or jailed for merely harvesting coconuts.

 

A report released June 10 by a group of German observers from the International Peace Observer Network (Ipon) noted that no cases of physical harassment against farmers were documented during the first quarter of 2007. Ipon advocates for peace and protection for farmers.

 

The lack of crops to harvest as a result of the typhoons in December 2006 prevented the interaction between owners and farmers, and the May 14 elections could have made the landowners amicable to the voters—the farmers and their families—resulting in a lull in the agrarian conflict in the area, Ipon noted in its report.

 

Typhoons, elections

 

“Most of the coconut trees in the Bondoc Peninsula have been severely damaged by the typhoon. Due to this, the next possible harvest will only be in August 2007 … That means if there is no coconut harvest, there is no sharing of the harvest, which often leads to conflict,” the group said.

 

The Hamburg-based peace advocates also said many of the members of the landowning families ran for different offices during the May 14 elections.

 

Two sons of the late Don Domingo Reyes, the biggest landlord in Bondoc with about 13,000 hectares in Buenavista, San Andres and San Narciso towns, were both incumbent mayors but lost in the May 14 elections.

 

Legal harassment

 

The situation slightly improved, according to Ipon, because the farmers were being organized under the Kilusang Magbubukid sa Bondoc Peninsula (KMBP) which advocates the protection of the rights of peasants in the area.

 

But while the physical harassment stopped, the harassment through the legal system was continuing, according to Ipon.

 

“Using the legal system of the Philippines through the filing of criminal cases against farmers can be seen as an effective instrument of harassment by the landowners,” Ipon observed.

 

Systematic

 

There were 259 criminal cases filed against 380 farmers from San Francisco, San Andres, San Narciso and Mulanay, the group documented. The cases range from theft of coconuts, estafa, libel, trespassing, grave threat, malicious mischief, attempted murder and homicide.

 

There were also 68 warrants of arrests against farmers of these municipalities, Ipon reported.

 

On May 7, Ipon accompanied 65 farmers from San Francisco to a hearing on the case of alleged coconut theft filed by a landowner at the regional trial court in Gumaca.

 

Ipon noted that the number of allegedly stolen coconuts in the case filed was very small and that nobody was present on behalf of the claimant, which was often the case during court hearings that usually lasted no more than 40 minutes.

 

“This may underline the assumption that the filed case seems to be more of a systematic harassment of the landowner than a real concern,” said the group.

 

The threat of violence was still a problem, Ipon added. “Because many farmers have been forced to stop petitioning, some decided to move to other sitios (subvillage) in order to live free from fear of physical attacks.”

 

Most of the farmers in these landholdings have to work under a 60-40, sometimes 75-25 percent sharing system in favor of the landowners, according to an Ipon report.

Palace: Fr. Mercado not chief negotiator

By Juliet Labog-Javellana
Inquirer
Last updated 01:10am (Mla time) 06/20/2007

MANILA, Philippines – Malacañang yesterday denied that Catholic priest Fr. Eliseo Mercado Jr. has been appointed chief government negotiator for the Moro Islamic Liberation Front following the abrupt resignation of Silvestre Afable Jr. on Friday.

 

“I believe the process for a suitable replacement is still in effect and the announcement will be made at the proper time,” Press Secretary Ignacio Bunye told reporters yesterday.

 

Bunye made the clarification days after Presidential Peace Adviser Jesus Dureza announced on Saturday that Mercado would replace Afable as chair of the government peace panel for the talks with the MILF.

 

Embarrassment

 

Bunye’s clarification could put Mercado in an embarrassing situation since he had welcomed his appointment and had expressed confidence he could contribute to the resolution of the decades-old Bangsamoro problem.

 

Bunye’s clarification also came after the MILF objected to Mercado’s appointment, saying he did not carry the authority of someone like Afable who has a Cabinet rank.

 

The MILF also said in its website that Dureza and National Security Adviser Norberto Gonzales eased out Afable, who had been chief peace negotiator since 2003.

 

Dureza, in an interview on ANC, confirmed that the MILF objection led to the withdrawal of Mercado’s appointment.

 

Dureza blamed

 

“As you know the MILF is the partner here in the negotiations so we have to make sure that that is something the partner accepts,” Dureza said. He said he tried to convince the MILF panel that Mercado is competent enough to be chief negotiator but he received a text message yesterday that a reconsideration (of Mercado’s appointment) may no longer be possible. He said he would submit new names to President Macapagal-Arroyo.

 

Before Dureza’s television interview, Bunye blamed his office for the latest mixup in Malacañang.

 

“Our announcement was quite clear. There was some confusion because of an announcement coming from another agency which that agency clarified,” Bunye said.

 

Bunye stood by his statement last Saturday confirming the resignation of Afable. He said that day that “there is now a search for his replacement.”

 

But shortly after Bunye issued his statement on Saturday, a statement from Dureza’s office was received in media offices saying Mercado is Afable’s replacement. Dureza said Mercado is an “experienced peace-builder in Mindanao” and that his immediate appointment would ensure a “seamless transition” from Afable’s resignation.

 

Bunye said Dureza made a clarification about his erroneous announcement the following day. Told by reporters there was none, Bunye said: “This is something we should sort out. I believe Secretary Dureza was the one who made the announcement, he should be the one to make the clarification.”

 

Asked if it meant Dureza was not authorized or was wrong in announcing the replacement, Bunye said: “Please don’t put words into my mouth. Let me just say that Secretary Afable has resigned and we’re looking for a replacement.”

 

Asked why he refused to make the clarification himself when he is the President’s spokesperson, Bunye said: “That is correct but this is something that was made by another agency.”

 

Bunye said the resignation of Afable should not disrupt the peace process with the MILF.

 

“I believe we have made sufficient progress in the peace process which will not be easily set aside by the resignation of Secretary Afable and even after the effectivity of the assignment of the replacement, Secretary Afable has committed to act as adviser for the peace panel,” Bunye said.

3 Filipinos killed in Abu Dhabi road accident

INQUIRER.net
Last updated 11:44am (Mla time) 06/20/2007uae.gif

MANILA, Philippines — Three Filipinos have died in a road accident in Abu Dhabi, the Department of Foreign Affairs has said in a statement to media.

 

Quoting Libran N. Cabactulan, Philippine Ambassador to the United Arab Emirates (UAE), the DFA said that brothers Jay-Ar and Emanuel de San Jose and Emanuel’s wife Charmaine were crossing the Sinaiyah road on their way to the St. Mary’s Church in Al Ain when they were hit by a car driven by a 19-year-old UAE national last June 14.

 

The two brothers died on the spot while Charmaine was still alive when she was brought to Al Jimi Hospital, where she died despite doctors’ efforts to save her, the DFA said.

 

Upon learning of the accident, Ambassador Cabactulan sent Assistance-to-Nationals (ATN) Officer Carlito Dizon to Al Ain to help the brothers’ mother, who is also a worker there, the DFA said.

 

The mother has been admitted to the Al Jimi Psychiatric Department due to shock over the untimely deaths of her two sons and daughter-in-law, the DFA said.

 

The driver of the car was also admitted to the Tawam Hospital in Al Ain after suffering from shock. He is under police custody, the DFA said quoting Cabactulan.

 

Emanuel de San Jose was working in a trading company in Dubai; his wife Charmaine was newly hired by an advertising agency in Al Ain; and Jay-Ar was a holder of a visit visa in Dubai, the DFA said.

 

The Embassy and the Philippine Overseas Labor Office (POLO) continues to extend assistance to the victims’ family, the DFA said.

Vatican issues ‘10 Commandments’ for drivers

Associated Press022_st-peters-square-vatican-city.jpg
Last updated 10:25am (Mla time) 06/20/2007

VATICAN CITY — The Vatican has issued a “Ten Commandments” for motorists to keep them on the road to salvation, warning drivers against the sins of road rage, abuse of alcohol or even simple rudeness.

 

The unusual document from the Vatican’s office for migrants and itinerant people also warned that automobiles can be “an occasion of sin” — particularly when used to make a dangerous passing maneuver or when used by prostitutes and their clients.

 

And it suggested prayer might come in handy –performing the sign of the cross before starting off and saying the rosary along the way. The rosary was particularly well-suited to recitation by all in the car, it said, since its “rhythm and gentle repetition does not distract the driver’s attention.”

 

Cardinal Renato Martino, who heads the office, told a news conference the Vatican felt it necessary to address the pastoral needs of motorists because driving has become such a big part of contemporary life.

 

He cited World Health Organization statistics that said an estimated 1.2 million people are killed in road crashes each year and as many as 50 million are injured.

 

“That’s a sad reality, and at the same time, a great challenge for society and the church,” he said.

 

He noted that the Bible was full of people on the move, including Mary and Joseph, the parents of Jesus — and that his office is tasked with dealing with all “itinerant” people on the roads — from refugees to prostitutes, truck drivers and the homeless.

 

The document, “Guidelines for the Pastoral Care of the Road,” extols the benefits of driving — family outings, getting the sick to the hospital, allowing people to get to work and seeing other cultures.

 

But it laments a host of ills associated with automobiles: Drivers use their cars to show off; driving “provides an easy opportunity to dominate others” by speeding; and drivers can kill themselves and others if they drink, use drugs or fall asleep at the wheel.

 

It warned about the effects of road rage, saying driving can bring out “primitive” behavior in motorists, including “impoliteness, rude gestures, cursing, blasphemy, loss of sense of responsibility or deliberate infringement of the highway code.”

 

It called for drivers to obey speed limits and to exercise a host of Christian virtues: charity to fellow drivers, prudence on the roads, hope of arriving safely and justice in the event of crashes.

 

Martino’s initiative was sure to make headlines in Italy, where car culture is deeply entrenched — this is the home of Ferrari and Fiat — and where weekend highway deaths make the evening news on a regular basis.gregorian.jpg

 

The Reverend Keith Pecklers, a Jesuit professor of liturgy at the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome, said Martino was clearly responding to an underreported social concern: an increase in traffic deaths in places like Italy and Spain because of speeding, as well as an increase in road rage, aggressive driving and DUI in places like the United States.

 

“It may be surprising for people because we’re accustomed to the church speaking out about sexual matters, capital punishment, immigration,” he said. “The point Cardinal Martino is making is that driving is itself a moral issue. How we drive impacts on the lives of ourselves and others.”

 

Pecklers dismissed any suggestion that Martino’s “Ten Commandments” were at all sacrilegious, saying it was “creative pedagogy” that would certainly get people’s attention. He stressed that they could never be considered binding in the way the official Ten Commandments are.

 

The Rev. Thomas Williams, a Rome-based theologian, concurred.

 

“It might be a little flippant but it’s not sacrilegious,” he said.

 

But for some, the document was at least reason to poke fun at the Vatican.

 

“Overtaking is a sin? Well, then I’m a murderer, I’ll turn myself in immediately,” quipped movie director Dino Risi, whose classic film “The Easy Life” — “Il Sorpasso,” or “The Overtaking” — ends with a car crash.

 

“I think the Vatican has lost its marbles,” he added, according to the ANSA news agency.

 

There was no indication Pope Benedict XVI had approved of, or even read, the document. It was signed by Martino and his secretary — as is customary for lower-level documents that are routinely put out by the offices of the Vatican’s vast bureaucracy.

 

Martino is known as something of a loose cannon at the Vatican, and occasionally his pronouncements have gotten him into trouble.pope_jpg

 

In 2003, he was rebuked by Vatican officials for telling a press conference the United States treated Saddam Hussein “like a cow” after his capture. A senior Vatican official called in reporters several days later to stress that Martino was expressing his personal opinion and not the view of the pope.

 

Martino hasn’t shied away from controversial topics, either. Just last week he said Roman Catholics should stop donating money to Amnesty International because it had adopted a new policy calling for women to have access to abortion services in some circumstances.

 

The cardinal, who was the Vatican’s UN envoy for 16 years, has also expressed support for genetically modified foods and he has backed scientists who question the seriousness of climate change.

Koko Pimentel takes case to SC

Koko Pimentel takes case to SC

Petition seeks to halt Maguindanao vote count

By Nikko Dizon, Jerome Aning, Jeoffrey Maitem, Ryan Rosauro
Inquirer, Mindanao Bureau
Last updated 02:01am (Mla time) 06/20/2007

MANILA, Philippines — His hopes hanging in the balance, Genuine Opposition (GO) candidate Aquilino “Koko” Pimentel III said he was filing in the Supreme Court on Wednesday a petition to stop the Commission on Elections from canvassing disputed vote tallies from Maguindanao, which could push Juan Miguel Zubiri of Team Unity (TU) past him in their battle for the last Senate slot.

 

The filing of the petition would coincide with Wednesday’s trip to General Santos City of a three-man Comelec panel led by Chair Benjamin Abalos for a meeting with Maguindanao poll officials on alleged vote fraud in the province during the May 14 elections.

 

Instead of going directly to Maguindanao, the Comelec panel has decided to meet with the province’s 22 election officers and their provincial supervisor, Lintang Bedol, in General Santos City.

 

“We will ask the Supreme Court to prevent the Comelec from using for canvassing the figures they will get from any documents gathered from Maguindanao,” Pimentel told the Philippine Daily Inquirer by phone.

 

Pimentel said he doubted the veracity of whatever election documents the Comelec team would be able to gather, pointing out that more than a month had passed since the elections.

 

“These documents are no longer trustworthy,” he said.

 

Opposition lawyers have expressed the fear that the vote tallies that Maguindanao poll officials would submit had been “manufactured.”

 

Security concerns

 

Comelec spokesperson James Jimenez said that in General Santos City, the poll inspectors “will be able to talk freely” and this would also ease security problems.

 

Pimentel said he was filing Wednesday a petition for prohibition and certiorari against Abalos and Commissioners Rene Sarmiento and Nicodemo Ferrer, who will accompany the Comelec chair on the trip.

 

Abalos and Ferrer plan to remain in General Santos while Sarmiento will make a side trip to Lanao del Sur, which was also the scene of alleged poll cheating.

 

Comelec’s tabulation of the Maguindanao provincial certificate of canvass (CoC), or vote tallies, was stalled by allegations that in some areas, public school teachers were forced by armed men to write down the names of TU senatorial candidates on the ballots.

 

In other areas, gunmen filled out the ballots themselves.

 

The incidents allegedly occurred in several barangays (villages) in the town of Pagalungan.

 

Plea for fairness

 

Based on the Comelec’s last official tally, Pimentel is ahead of Zubiri by more than 111,000 votes, without the Maguindanao tally.

 

Lawyers of both GO and TU said that with the Maguindanao votes, Zubiri would knock Pimentel off 12th place. An unofficial Maguindanao tally shown to reporters gave Zubiri 195,823 votes against Pimentel’s 67,057 votes.

 

Zubiri has been urging the Comelec to go ahead with the tabulation of the Maguindanao votes.

 

Abalos on Tuesday said it was unfair of GO to conclude that the poll documents from Maguindanao were fake.

 

“Let us see, let us not just say they are manufactured. Anyhow, once they are presented, they have the right to object to all of these,” Abalos told reporters.

 

Comelec has been looking for the municipal certificates of canvass from the province that were supposed to back the provincial CoC showing the TU senatorial slate winning all the top 12 spots.

 

Bedol’s proof

 

Comelec officials themselves have expressed doubts about the provincial tallies, saying it was “statistically improbable” for 19 out of the 37 senatorial candidates to have received no votes at all.

 

Task Force Maguindanao, chaired by Ferrer, was formed to investigate alleged election fraud in the province.

 

Bedol caused a stir when he came to Manila and told Comelec officials that his copies of vote tallies had been stolen.

 

Abalos earlier said the Maguindanao municipal election officers had told Comelec they could not go to Manila for lack of funds. Instead, they asked that the commissioners come to Maguindanao.

 

Regional Gov. Zaldy Ampatuan has presented a copy of the minutes of the provincial canvassing signed by Bedol and other members of the provincial Board of Canvassers. Abalos said this might prove that elections were indeed held.

 

The findings of the Abalos team would be evaluated by the Comelec en banc prior to a ruling on the Maguindanao fiasco.

 

If the documents were proved authentic, Abalos said, the special provincial board of canvassers would be reconstituted to tally the votes for the national positions — senator and party-lists.

 

Opposition boycott

 

GO lead counsel Sixto Brillantes said the opposition party would not join the Abalos trip on Wednesday.

 

“We do not intend to participate in the Maguindanao trip. Anyway, it is very much like a fishing expedition because they’re going there even if they don’t even know what documents they are seeking,” he told reporters.

 

TU lawyer Romulo Macalintal said his clients would join the Abalos trip and thus end the controversy plaguing the Maguindanao voting results.

 

“TU is ready to go there and see for itself the proof that elections were held in Maguindanao, based on the documents that the election officers are said to present,” he said.

 

Doubts about the figures reflected in the CoC from Maguindanao deepened when Bedol claimed his copies were stolen from his office.

 

The municipal CoCs and statement of votes should support figures reflected in the provincial CoC.

 

Ampatuan: Elections held

 

Maguindanao Gov. Andal Ampatuan has repeatedly said that elections were held in his province and that the victory of TU was the result of consultations among local leaders.

 

Fr. David Procalla, coordinator of the Parish Pastoral Council for Responsible Voting (PPCRV), which monitored the voting in six towns, said elections were held in the province.ppcrvseal1.jpg

 

“It’s unfair to come to that conclusion (that no elections took place) just because the PPCRV was only able to deploy volunteers in those areas,” Procalla earlier told the Inquirer.

COLORS OF HOMAGE

Members of various Rizalista groups nationwide gather together to form a human flag at the Quirino Grandstand in Luneta, Manila as tribute to Dr. Jose Rizal’s 146th birth anniversary. INQUIRER/RAFFY LERMA